The Supreme Court on Tuesday dismissed the Uttar Pradesh government’s challenge to an Allahabad High Court order staying the conviction of Samajwadi Party leader Mohammad Azam Khan in the alleged forged birth certificate case involving his son, Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan. The Court also allowed appeals filed by Azam Khan’s wife, Dr. Tazeen Fatima, and Abdullah Azam Khan, granting them the benefit of a stay on their convictions.
A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu passed the order while hearing a batch of connected petitions arising from the High Court’s May 24, 2024 decision. The State government had challenged the relief granted to Azam Khan, while his wife and son had approached the Supreme Court against the High Court’s refusal to stay their convictions.
“We have dismissed the appeal of the State government. We have allowed the appeals of Abdullah Azam Khan and Tazeen Fatima,” the Bench observed while pronouncing its decision.
Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal appeared for Azam Khan and Tazeen Fatima.
The proceedings stemmed from allegations that Azam Khan and his wife had facilitated the procurement of two birth certificates for their son, carrying different dates and places of birth.
The FIR was registered on January 3, 2019, at Ganj Police Station in Rampur following a complaint by BJP leader Akash Saxena, who is now an MLA from Rampur. The complaint alleged that two separate birth certificates had been obtained for Abdullah Azam, one issued by the Nagar Palika Parishad, Rampur, on June 28, 2012, and another by the Lucknow Municipal Corporation on January 21, 2015.
While the Rampur certificate mentioned January 1, 1993, as Abdullah’s date of birth and Rampur as his birthplace, the Lucknow document recorded September 30, 1990, as his date of birth, with Queen Mary’s Hospital in Lucknow listed as his birthplace.
According to the prosecution, the two documents were used for different official purposes, including passport-related records and government documentation. The alleged discrepancy also became significant during Abdullah’s candidature from the Suar Assembly constituency in the 2017 Uttar Pradesh elections.
On October 18, 2023, a special court in Rampur convicted Azam Khan, Fatima and Abdullah for offences including cheating, forgery, use of forged documents and criminal conspiracy under the Indian Penal Code. All three were sentenced to seven years of imprisonment.
Their appeals against the conviction were subsequently rejected by the appellate court, following which they approached the Allahabad High Court through criminal revision petitions.
On May 24, 2024, the High Court suspended the sentences of all three accused and granted them bail. However, it granted a stay on conviction only to Azam Khan, declining similar relief to his wife and son.
The High Court had distinguished Azam Khan’s alleged role from that of the other two accused, observing that the prosecution had failed to demonstrate material evidence establishing his direct involvement in supplying the information on the basis of which the disputed birth certificate was obtained. It also questioned the prosecution’s reliance on a hospital document which, according to the court, was dated later than the birth certificate itself.
The High Court further took note of the fact that officials responsible for issuing the two birth certificates had neither been examined during the investigation nor produced as witnesses at trial.
Aggrieved by the differential treatment, Fatima and Abdullah moved the Supreme Court seeking the same protection granted to Azam Khan. The Uttar Pradesh government, meanwhile, challenged the suspension of his conviction.
With Tuesday’s decision, the Supreme Court has rejected the State’s challenge and extended the benefit of suspension of conviction to Azam Khan’s wife and son as well.
Case Title: State of Uttar Pradesh v. Mohammad Azam Khan & Ors., SLP (Crl.) Nos. 11030–11032 of 2025 and connected matters.
The post Supreme Court dismisses UP Government’s appeal against stay on Azam Khan’s conviction; grants same relief to wife, son appeared first on India Legal.
