LAWYER SIBLING LOGO (1)
  • Home
  • Blogs
  • News
  • Updates
  • Constitution
    • Constitutional Laws
  • Laws
    • Civil Law
    • Criminal Law
    • Family Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Business Law
    • Cyber & IT Law
    • Employee Law
    • Finance Law
    • International Law
  • Special Act
    • Motor Vehicles Act (MV Act)
    • Consumer Protection Act
    • Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Act (NDPS)
    • The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO)
  • Bare Act

Dissent is not defection: Skipping party meeting does not mean giving up membership, Eknath Shinde tells Supreme Court

18/11/2026BlogNo Comments

Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde has told the Supreme Court that dissent within a political party cannot be equated with defection and that legislators cannot be disqualified merely for refusing to attend a meeting convened by the party leadership.

Appearing for Shinde and other MLAs of his faction, Senior Advocate Dhruv Mehta argued that absence from a legislative party meeting does not amount to voluntarily giving up membership of the political party, which is a ground for disqualification under Paragraph 2(1)(a) of the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution.

The submissions were made before a three-judge Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, which is hearing the challenge filed by the Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray faction against the Maharashtra Assembly Speaker’s decision declining to disqualify Shinde faction legislators under the anti-defection law.

Mehta questioned how the failure to attend a legislative party meeting could be treated as relinquishment of membership of the political party itself. He pointed out that the disqualification petitions filed by Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Sunil Prabhu against the Shinde faction MLAs primarily relied on their absence from a meeting convened on June 21, 2022, ahead of the Maharashtra Legislative Council elections.

The senior counsel submitted that the allegations in the disqualification petitions referred to the legislators having given up membership of the Shiv Sena Legislative Party and remaining absent from the meeting despite being aware of its significance. However, he argued that such allegations did not establish that the legislators had voluntarily abandoned their membership of the political party, as contemplated under the Tenth Schedule.

Mehta also disputed the characterisation of the June 21 communication as a binding whip. According to him, a WhatsApp message calling the legislators to attend the meeting was sent to Shinde’s personal assistant at 12.31 pm, whereas the meeting had commenced at 12.30 pm. He argued that the communication was merely an invitation to attend a meeting and could not be treated as a formal whip.

He further pointed out that no agenda had been circulated and no resolution was passed at the meeting. Referring to Sunil Prabhu’s cross-examination, Mehta submitted that the latter had acknowledged that the meeting was convened because the Shinde faction legislators could not be contacted and was intended as an attempt at reconciliation.

The senior counsel also questioned the reliance placed by the Thackeray faction on an attendance register to establish that the Shinde camp legislators had defied the party’s directions. He argued that the petitioners’ position was internally contradictory, as they simultaneously relied on signatures in the register while seeking disqualification of the legislators whose signatures allegedly appeared on it.

Describing the signatures as fabricated, Mehta alleged that signatures of two individuals had been forged and inserted into the register. He submitted that the Speaker had also found the attendance register unreliable and pointed to Prabhu’s response during cross-examination regarding the discrepancies.

Beyond the circumstances surrounding the June 2022 meeting, Mehta argued that the rebellion by the Shinde faction was rooted in a disagreement with the political direction adopted by the then party leadership under Uddhav Thackeray. He maintained that the legislators had not abandoned the Shiv Sena but sought to restore what they regarded as the party’s original ideological orientation and political alignment.

Referring to the party’s 2019 electoral alliance with the Bharatiya Janata Party, Mehta submitted that the Shiv Sena had contested the Maharashtra Assembly elections alongside the BJP on a common political platform. He argued that the subsequent decision of the Thackeray leadership to break the alliance and form the Maha Vikas Aghadi government with the Congress and the Nationalist Congress Party was contrary to the political understanding on which the alliance had sought the electorate’s mandate.

Mehta also traced the evolution of the Shiv Sena’s organisational structure, referring to its 1999 constitution, which provided for elected organisational bodies such as the Rashtriya Karyakarini and the Pratinidhi Sabha. He argued that amendments made in 2018 substantially altered this framework by concentrating powers relating to appointments and removals of office-bearers in the hands of the Paksha Pramukh.

The senior counsel contended that the Tenth Schedule was not intended to penalise every instance of disagreement within a political party. A legislator, he argued, could oppose the incumbent leadership or seek a change in the party’s political course without necessarily ceasing to be a member of that party. Whether particular conduct crossed the statutory threshold for disqualification would have to be examined on the facts of each case.

The Supreme Court is also considering a connected petition filed by Uddhav Thackeray challenging the Election Commission of India’s decision recognising the Shinde faction as the official Shiv Sena and permitting it to use the party’s ‘bow and arrow’ election symbol.

The principal disqualification challenge was instituted by Sunil Prabhu against the Speaker’s January 10, 2024 decision refusing to disqualify legislators belonging to the Shinde faction. The arguments on behalf of Shinde’s side remained inconclusive and were scheduled to continue before the Bench on November 18.

The post Dissent is not defection: Skipping party meeting does not mean giving up membership, Eknath Shinde tells Supreme Court appeared first on India Legal.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • CJI Surya Kant launches book on China, says it could find place on desk of future writers
  • Doors opened by Cornelia Sorabji must remain open for women: Justice BV Nagarathna at Oxford
  • Justice Rajesh Bindal takes charge as NCLAT chairperson
  • Restaurants, Hotels cannot impose mandatory service charge: Delhi High Court clarifies no interim protection granted against ban
  • Election Commission has limited powers against BLAs filing fake form 7 applications to delete voters: Supreme Court

Recent Comments

  1. Phone Tracking In India - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA
  2. Section 437A of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA
  3. The Evolution of Indian Penal Code 1860: Key Provisions and Relevance Today - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA

Follow us for more

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
YouTube
Instagram
DisclaimerPrivacy PolicyTerms and Conditions
All Rights Reserved © 2023
  • Login
  • Sign Up
Forgot Password?
Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.