The Gujarat High Court has extended the parole of seven convicts serving life sentences in the 2002 Godhra train burning case by three weeks, observing that they cannot be made to suffer on account of the State government’s failure to take a decision on their applications seeking remission of sentence.
Justice D.N. Ray, by separate orders passed on November 17, extended the parole granted to the seven convicts until December 10, 2026, when their applications seeking further extension will be considered. The Court also directed that the report submitted by the Additional Public Prosecutor be taken on record.
The seven convicts Mehboob Yakub Mitha alias Popa Shaikh, Mehboob Ahmed Yusuf Hassan alias Latifo Ghanchi, Jabir Bin Yamin Bahera Ghanchi, Ramjani Bin Yamin Bahera Ghanchi, Sokat Yusuf Ismail Mohan alias Bibino Ghanchi, Siraj Mohd. Abdul Raheman Meda alias Lal and Anwar Mahamad Meda alias Lala Shaikh had approached the High Court seeking continuation of the parole granted to them earlier.
The applications arose after the State government failed to conclude the reconsideration of their pleas for premature release, despite an earlier judicial direction to take a decision within a stipulated period.
The issue had come up before the High Court in July this year, when it directed the competent authorities to reconsider the convicts’ remission applications and take an appropriate decision expeditiously, preferably within four months of receiving the order.
Taking into account the prolonged period of incarceration undergone by the convicts, the Court had also permitted their release on parole for four months or until the State authorities took a fresh decision on their remission pleas, whichever occurred earlier.
When the matter was taken up again on November 17, the State opposed the request for extending parole, informing the Court that the remission applications were still under consideration.
The Court, however, questioned the position adopted by the State, observing that the authorities could not keep the remission applications pending while simultaneously opposing the convicts’ request for continuation of parole. It orally remarked that the delay in deciding their applications was not attributable to the convicts.
The High Court consequently extended the existing parole arrangement until December 10 and directed that the State’s report be placed on record. The extension does not amount to remission of their sentences or a final determination of their claims for premature release.
The seven applicants are among the 31 persons convicted by a special trial court in March 2011 for their involvement in the burning of the S-6 coach of the Sabarmati Express near Godhra railway station on February 28, 2002. The incident resulted in the deaths of 59 passengers, including kar sevaks returning from Ayodhya.
The trial court had awarded capital punishment to 11 convicts and sentenced the remaining 20 to life imprisonment, while acquitting 63 accused. In October 2017, the Gujarat High Court commuted the death sentences to life imprisonment and upheld the life sentences imposed on the other convicts.
The criminal appeals arising from the convictions remain pending before the Supreme Court. The State government has also challenged the High Court’s decision commuting the death sentences.
The latest order is confined to continuation of parole and does not decide the merits of the pending remission applications or the criminal appeals.
The post Gujarat High Court extends parole of seven Godhra Train burning convicts till December 10 amid pending remission pleas appeared first on India Legal.
