The Supreme Court on Thursday declined to interfere with the interim bail granted to senior Samajwadi Party leader Mohd Azam Khan in a money laundering case linked to alleged financial irregularities involving the Mohammad Ali Jauhar University. The Court dismissed the Enforcement Directorate’s challenge to the Allahabad High Court order, while clarifying that the High Court’s prima facie observations on the legality of Khan’s arrest should not influence the final consideration of his bail plea.
A Bench of Justice MM Sundresh and Justice PB Varale was hearing the ED’s appeal against the November 17 order of the Allahabad High Court granting interim bail to Khan. The agency had questioned the High Court’s findings concerning the circumstances in which Khan was arrested and the alleged failure to furnish him with written grounds of arrest.
Additional Solicitor General SV Raju, appearing for the ED, contended that the High Court had proceeded on an incorrect factual premise. He submitted that the investigating agency had duly attempted to serve the grounds of arrest on Khan, but he had refused to accept the documents. Referring to the material available with the agency, Raju told the Bench that the arrest proceedings had been videographed and a panchnama had also been prepared to document the alleged refusal.
The law officer sought to demonstrate that the ED had complied with the statutory and constitutional requirements governing arrest, and argued that the High Court’s observations questioning the agency’s conduct were not supported by the complete factual record.
The Supreme Court, however, was not inclined to disturb an order granting interim relief. The Bench observed that the findings recorded by the High Court were only prima facie in nature and could not be treated as determinative when the regular bail application was eventually considered.
“This being an interim order, we are not inclined to interfere. The views of the High Court being prima facie may not have a bearing while deciding the matter finally,” the Bench observed.
When Raju pointed out that Khan’s regular bail plea would also be heard by the same High Court Bench that had questioned the circumstances of his arrest, the Supreme Court declined to attribute any motive to the High Court. It indicated that the observations made while granting interim bail should not weigh with the court at the stage of final adjudication.
“We can’t attribute motive to the (High) Court,” the Bench remarked, before dismissing the ED’s appeal.
The Allahabad High Court had granted Khan interim bail after examining the circumstances surrounding his arrest on October 31. The 78-year-old politician was taken into ED custody shortly after being released from Rampur district jail upon securing bail in a separate case relating to alleged irregularities involving dual PAN cards.
A Bench of Justice Rajiv Gupta and Justice Devendra Singh had expressed serious reservations about the manner in which the arrest was carried out. It observed that Khan had been taken into custody at the jail gate shortly after his release in the other case, a circumstance which, in its prima facie assessment, indicated the “motivated and mala fide nature” of the proceedings.
The High Court had also examined whether the ED complied with Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 19 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, which govern the communication of grounds of arrest. It noted that the arrest memo, grounds of arrest and reasons to believe Khan’s involvement in the alleged offence did not appear to have been furnished to him in writing before his production for remand.
The agency had maintained that its officials verbally informed Khan about the grounds of arrest after he declined to receive the documents. However, the High Court observed that the material placed before it did not establish that an officer had actually offered the documents to Khan and that he had refused to accept them. It also took note of the absence of supporting video footage or photographs demonstrating such an exchange.
On this basis, the High Court was prima facie satisfied that the mandatory safeguards governing Khan’s arrest had not been strictly adhered to. It consequently granted him interim bail, directing his release upon furnishing the requisite personal bond and sureties. The relief was made operative until the next date of hearing, December 10, while the ED was granted time to file a detailed counter-affidavit.
The money laundering investigation against Khan arises from allegations of financial irregularities involving the Mohammad Ali Jauhar University and the Maulana Mohammad Ali Jauhar Trust, of which he is the founder. The ED initiated proceedings on the basis of multiple FIRs registered by the Uttar Pradesh Police in 2019. The allegations include diversion of government funds and materials intended for public works, irregularities in land acquisition and alleged routing of money to the trust.
Khan had challenged his arrest before the Supreme Court earlier, following which the matter was directed to be considered by the Allahabad High Court. The apex court’s latest decision leaves the interim bail protection undisturbed, while making it clear that the High Court must independently examine the question of regular bail without being influenced by its earlier prima facie observations.
The post Supreme Court refuses to interfere with Azam Khan’s interim bail in ED money laundering case appeared first on India Legal.
