By Pawan Kumar
This November 9, 2026, Professor Upendra Baxi celebrated his 89th birthday. Born on November 9, 1938, Prof Baxi is the most influential legal theorist and law professor in India and arguably in the world. Prof Baxi stands among the most uncompromising voices in modern Indian legal scholarship. His intellectual work does not fit into the familiar categories of doctrinal analysis, liberal rights theory, or conventional constitutional commentary. Instead, he interrogates law as an instrument that simultaneously promises justice and enables structural violence. His writings cut through celebratory narratives of Indian constitutionalism and expose the complex interactions between state power, corporate influence, human rights discourse, and global governance. The depth of his critique, the range of his interventions, and the consistency of his moral stance have made him one of the most influential legal theorists.
Prof Baxi or Upen, as he fondly refers to himself, received his early legal education at Government Law College, Bombay, where he earned his LL.B. and LL.M. degrees. Is it noteworthy to mention that the father of our Constitution, Dr. B.R Ambedkar was then the principal of GLC when Prof Baxi was a student! He then obtained a Master of Laws and a Doctor of Juridical Science (S.J.D.) from the University of California, Berkeley.
After completing his doctorate, he began his academic career with roles at the University of Sydney and then joined the Faculty of Law at the University of Delhi from 1973 to 1996. While at Delhi, he held numerous leadership roles, including Dean of the Faculty of Law and later Vice-Chancellor (1990–1994). He also served as Vice-Chancellor of South Gujarat University (1982–1985). He was also the Honorary Director (Research) of the Indian Law Institute, New Delhi from 1985 to 1988. My first opportunity to meet Prof Baxi was at the institute only where I was a doctoral student somewhere around 2018.
In the mid-1990s, Baxi became Professor of Law in Development at the University of Warwick, United Kingdom, where he is now Professor Emeritus. His academic journey spans multiple continents and generations, positioning him as a leader in intellectual thought, teaching innovation, and public engagement. Prof Baxi’s work in human rights stands out for its moral depth and its focus on “the suffering subject” as the core of law. He believes that discussions of rights should come from the real experiences of marginalized and oppressed people, rather than from abstract liberal ideas. It is evidenced by the fact that University of Sydney, where Prof Baxi started his academic career, came to Delhi to confer him Doctor of Laws (honoris causa)/ LLD in recognition of his innovative legal scholarship and his unwavering pursuit of social justice on August 31, 2026 at New Delhi. This shows how great Prof Baxi is and in my words, he is the only rockstar law professor India ever had!
DEVELOPING A NEW JURISPRUDENCE
Prof Baxi’s early scholarship showed clear impatience with the way Indian legal academia imitated the methodological approaches of British and American jurisprudence. He argued that Indian law could not be understood through borrowed conceptual frameworks because such frameworks erased the lived realities of poverty, caste hierarchies, state authoritarianism, and institutional failure. He insisted that Indian jurisprudence must be grounded in social suffering and material conditions. His emphasis on the “politics of interpretation” signalled a shift away from abstract doctrinarism and toward a sociology of law that exposed how courts reproduce dominant power structures even when they claim to protect rights.
Rather than accepting the Indian constitutional project as inherently emancipatory. Constantly, he challenged the gap between constitutional ideals and everyday injustice. He criticised the self-congratulatory tone with which the Indian judiciary commemorated landmark judgments while ignoring the widespread inaccessibility of legal remedies for the vast majority of citizens. This early intellectual stance shaped the rest of his career and remains foundational to understanding his scholarship.
His contributions to human rights theory are both expansive and sharply critical. He refused to treat human rights as universal moral principles that operate outside political and economic power. For him, human rights exist within networks of global governance shaped by corporate actors, transnational institutions, and postcolonial states. His well known distinction between ‘trade related’, ‘market friendly’ human rights and ‘insurgent’ human rights captured the ongoing struggle between two competing visions of legality. The first vision aligns with neoliberal institutions that instrumentalise rights for economic liberalisation and global capital. The second vision represents bottom up movements, marginalised groups, and communities resisting dispossession and exploitation.
Prof Baxi’s constitutional scholarship disrupts the standard liberal narrative that portrays the Indian judiciary as the guardian of civil liberties. He has never idealised the courts. Instead, he subjects judicial power to rigorous scrutiny. His earliest critiques of the Emergency period, particularly his writing on the Supreme Court’s conduct in the ADM Jabalpur case, remain some of the sharpest commentaries on judicial complicity in executive excess. For Prof Baxi, constitutionalism cannot be judged by celebrated doctrines alone. It must be evaluated through the actual behaviour of institutions during moments of crisis.
His engagement with Public Interest Litigation demonstrates the same critical but constructive approach. He preferred to call PIL and Social Action Litigations, the best suitable title. He has acknowledged the transformative potential of PIL during the 1980s, especially for victims of bonded labour, custodial violence, and displacement. Yet he also pinpointed the dangers of judicial overreach, paternalism, and the tendency of PIL jurisprudence to place judges in the role of benevolent administrators rather than constitutional arbiters. His approach prevents blind celebration and insists on institutional accountability.
Prof Baxi’s analysis of the Bhopal gas disaster remains one of the most powerful examinations of corporate crime in Indian legal literature. He meticulously documented how the State, the judiciary, and multinational corporations collaborated, whether intentionally or structurally, to shield corporate actors from full accountability. He criticized the Supreme Court settlement as an instance of “juridical defeatism” and exposed the legal architecture that allowed Union Carbide to escape the scale of responsibility commensurate with the magnitude of harm caused.
JURISPRUDENCE POST BAXI IN INDIA
Developing a new theory of law post Upendra Baxi is not an easy task given his innumerable contributions. It would take years to grasp what he has written in more than 60 years of his academic life. For scholars based in the Global South, his major contribution is his writings challenging the Eurocentric foundations of international law. He argued that global legal institutions hide their historical complicity in colonial extraction and present themselves as neutral arbiters of international order. For him, the postcolonial State is constrained by international regulations that prioritise corporate interests and restrict policy space for welfare oriented governance. His engagement with global justice critiques both domestic authoritarianism and international structures that perpetuate inequality.
Baxi’s international law scholarship challenges a simple dichotomy between universal law and local experience. In ‘What May the “Third World” Expect from International Law?’, he treats the Third World as comprising both peoples and states and is quite emphatic about the need for the peoples of the Third World to be involved in the making of international law. He draws a distinction between histories which are centred on diplomatic authority and histories of struggle in which peoples are contesting domination.This is a direct challenge to the sort of account in which the societies of the former colonies are merely the recipients of the rules or the objects of imperial power.
Teaching jurisprudence after Baxi requires students to make the link between conceptual analysis and the actual conditions in which law is encountered and contested. It also requires teachers to subject their own authority to scrutiny. A genuine appreciation of Baxi’s contribution is embodied in a classroom that rigorously engages with his questions, even when students challenge his responses.
CONCLUSION
Upendra Baxi is not a scholar who offers comforting narratives about law’s progress or the triumph of rights. He exposes the violence that legal systems enable and challenges the legitimacy of institutions that operate under the façade of neutrality. His work is grounded in a moral and political commitment to the vulnerable. He insists that law must be evaluated through its effects on those who bear the brunt of injustice. This unwavering stance, combined with his rigorous critique of state power, corporate dominance, and global governance, makes him one of the most important legal theorists of the postcolonial world. His scholarship remains indispensable for anyone who wants to understand law without illusions and who is prepared to confront the harsh realities hidden behind legal doctrine and institutional rhetoric. When we were mourning the demise of his wife, Late Prema Baxi, Prof Baxi agreed to take the honorary doctorate by the University of Sydney where he started his academic career, showing commitment to his academia.
—The writer teaches at Amity Law School, Amity University, Noida
The post Developing Jurisprudence Post Upendra Baxi in India appeared first on India Legal.
