The Delhi High Court on Thursday clarified that restaurants and hotels cannot impose mandatory service charges on customers, making it clear that no interim protection has been granted against an earlier judgment prohibiting the practice. The clarification came while the Court was hearing appeals filed by restaurant industry associations challenging the ruling that upheld the Central Consumer Protection Authority’s (CCPA) guidelines against compulsory service charges.
A Division Bench comprising Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma was hearing appeals preferred by the National Restaurant Association of India (NRAI) and the Federation of Hotel and Restaurant Associations of India (FHRAI) against a March 28, 2025 judgment of a single judge. The Division Bench admitted the appeals for hearing but declined to grant any interim relief against the operation of the impugned judgment.
The issue came up after Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma, appearing for the government, informed the Court that certain restaurants continued to impose service charges compulsorily despite the earlier ruling. He submitted that such practices were contrary to the directions issued by the single judge and the CCPA guidelines, which prohibit automatic or default addition of service charges to food bills.
Responding to the submission, the Bench pointed out that it had not passed any interim order protecting restaurants from the operation of the single judge’s judgment. Acting Chief Justice Sambre observed that the authorities were at liberty to take appropriate action against establishments continuing the practice, as no interim protection had been granted to the restaurant associations.
The Bench remarked, “Ball is in your court. It is for you to take action. We can’t take action. Where is the interim relief? Where is the interim relief in their favour? We have not granted any interim prayer.”
The dispute originates from the CCPA guidelines issued on July 4, 2022, following numerous consumer complaints that hotels and restaurants were routinely adding service charges ranging between 5% and 20% to food bills without obtaining customers’ consent. The guidelines expressly prohibited establishments from adding such charges automatically or by default, collecting them under another name, or compelling customers to pay them as a condition for receiving services.
The NRAI and FHRAI subsequently approached the Delhi High Court challenging the guidelines, contending that the collection of service charges was a longstanding industry practice, followed for several decades and linked to arrangements concerning employees’ wages and compensation. They also questioned the CCPA’s authority to regulate the practice under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
However, in its March 2025 judgment, Justice Prathiba M Singh dismissed the petitions and upheld the validity and enforceability of the CCPA guidelines. The single judge held that service charges and tips constituted voluntary payments and could not be imposed as a compulsory component of a restaurant bill.
The Court had reasoned that consumers were required to pay the prices of food and beverages displayed on the menu, along with applicable statutory taxes. Any additional amount imposed without the customer’s consent amounted to an unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act.
It further held that the CCPA was statutorily empowered to issue guidelines for preventing unfair trade practices and protecting consumer interests. The Court emphasised that the collective rights of consumers could not be subordinated to the commercial interests of restaurant establishments.
The single judge also observed that describing such payments as ‘service charges’ could mislead consumers into believing that they were statutory levies such as service tax or GST. It suggested that the CCPA could consider permitting alternative descriptions, including ‘voluntary contribution’, ‘staff contribution’ or ‘staff welfare fund’, provided the payment remained entirely discretionary.
In their appeals before the Division Bench, the restaurant associations have maintained that service charges, when prominently disclosed on menus and within restaurant premises, cannot be characterised as an unfair trade practice. The NRAI has argued that the levy is an established industry practice recognised in various judicial decisions, wage board arrangements and labour settlements, and constitutes part of the compensation structure for employees.
The association has also questioned whether the regulation of such charges falls within the domain of labour law rather than consumer protection legislation, contending that the CCPA cannot interfere with pricing arrangements transparently disclosed to customers before they place orders.
With the Division Bench admitting the appeals but declining interim protection, the March 2025 judgment continues to operate. Restaurants and hotels, therefore, cannot make payment of service charges compulsory or add such amounts to customers’ bills by default. Any tip or contribution towards staff welfare must remain voluntary and subject to the customer’s discretion.
The post Restaurants, Hotels cannot impose mandatory service charge: Delhi High Court clarifies no interim protection granted against ban appeared first on India Legal.
