LAWYER SIBLING LOGO (1)
  • Home
  • Blogs
  • News
  • Updates
  • Constitution
    • Constitutional Laws
  • Laws
    • Civil Law
    • Criminal Law
    • Family Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Business Law
    • Cyber & IT Law
    • Employee Law
    • Finance Law
    • International Law
  • Special Act
    • Motor Vehicles Act (MV Act)
    • Consumer Protection Act
    • Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Act (NDPS)
    • The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO)
  • Bare Act

Supreme Court strikes down UP laws denying pension benefits for pre-regularisation service of work-charged employees

20/11/2026BlogNo Comments

The Supreme Court has struck down two Uttar Pradesh laws that excluded the service rendered by work-charged, temporary, daily-wage and muster-roll employees before their regularisation from the computation of qualifying service for pensionary benefits.

A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma declared the Uttar Pradesh Qualifying Service for Pension and Validation Act, 2021, and the Uttar Pradesh Entitlement to Pension and Validation Act, 2025, unconstitutional, holding that the State legislature had failed to remove the legal infirmity identified by the Supreme Court in its 2019 judgment in Prem Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh.

The Court held that once an employee’s services are regularised under a duly formulated scheme, the nature of the initial appointment cannot subsequently be invoked to deny pensionary entitlements for the preceding period of service.

“The act of regularisation obliterates the source or birthmark of the appointment simpliciter,” the Bench observed, emphasising that the character of service rendered before regularisation cannot, by itself, determine an employee’s eligibility for pension and other retirement benefits.

The controversy traces its origins to the Supreme Court’s 2019 decision in Prem Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh, in which the Court held that service rendered in a work-charged establishment must be taken into account while determining qualifying service for pension, particularly where employees were subsequently regularised.

The Court had read down Rule 3(8) of the Uttar Pradesh Retirement Benefits Rules, 1961, which excluded such service from pension computation.

However, the Uttar Pradesh government subsequently enacted the 2021 and 2025 validation laws, seeking to restrict pension eligibility through revised statutory definitions and retrospective validation of earlier decisions denying pensionary benefits.

The employees challenged these enactments, contending that the State had effectively sought to circumvent the binding directions issued by the Supreme Court in Prem Singh.

Writing the judgment, Justice Dipankar Datta explained that the validity of a validating legislation must be examined not merely on the basis of the legislature’s competence to enact it, but also by determining whether it has actually removed the defect identified in the earlier judicial pronouncement.

The Bench clarified that a legislature may retrospectively validate an action declared invalid by a court, but it must first eliminate the legal infirmity that led to the judicial intervention. Merely introducing a new statutory formulation or retrospectively declaring earlier actions valid would not satisfy this requirement.

Examining the 2021 legislation, the Court noted that it redefined qualifying service by linking pension eligibility to appointments made against temporary or permanent posts in accordance with applicable service rules. It also sought to retrospectively validate actions taken under Rule 3(8), including previous decisions denying pension, with effect from April 1, 1961.

The Court found that the amendment did not address the fundamental defect identified in Prem Singh, as it continued to exclude the relevant period of work-charged service.

The 2025 enactment also failed to withstand judicial scrutiny. It introduced the expression ‘substantive appointee’ and made pension entitlement dependent on the employee satisfying that classification. It further excluded certain employees who were or had been subscribers to the Contributory Provident Fund or Employees’ Provident Fund.

The Bench held that these legislative changes altered the terminology and eligibility framework without removing the underlying constitutional infirmity.

It observed that the State had effectively attempted to preserve the exclusion previously disapproved by the Supreme Court through a different statutory mechanism.

The Court relied on its earlier decisions, including Prithvi Cotton Mills v. Broach Borough Municipality, Indian Aluminium Co. v. State of Kerala and Madan Mohan Pathak v. Union of India, while reiterating the legal principles governing validating legislation.

It held that the constitutional validity of the two Uttar Pradesh enactments had to be assessed against the specific defect identified in the 2019 judgment, in addition to the ordinary requirements of constitutional scrutiny.

Concluding that the State had failed to cure the defect, the Bench declared both enactments ultra vires the Constitution.

While setting aside the impugned laws, the Supreme Court directed that pension claims of eligible work-charged employees be examined in accordance with the principles laid down in Prem Singh.

Retired government employees covered by the judgment have been permitted to approach the competent authorities with complete particulars of their past service. The authorities have been directed to examine such claims and determine entitlement to pension and other retiral benefits within six months of receiving the applications.

The Court also clarified that the monetary benefits would ordinarily be restricted to the three years preceding the institution of the writ petition in Prem Singh. This limitation, however, will not apply to claims made by legal heirs of employees who had retired and died before the 2019 judgment was delivered, subject to production of satisfactory proof of their entitlement.

The Bench further directed that any proposed rejection of a pension claim must be preceded by an opportunity of hearing and supported by a reasoned order. Authorities granting benefits must also provide employees with a detailed statement of the payments released under different heads.

Importantly, the Court directed that if the State fails to release the admissible pensionary benefits within the prescribed timelines, the outstanding amount will carry simple interest at nine per cent per annum until payment.

The State has also been granted a final period of six months to comply with the directions issued in Prem Singh in the pending contempt proceedings. The Bench cautioned that any further failure to comply could attract consequences of aggravated contempt.

The Court accordingly set aside the judgments and orders of the High Court that were under challenge in the connected civil appeals.

The post Supreme Court strikes down UP laws denying pension benefits for pre-regularisation service of work-charged employees appeared first on India Legal.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Supreme Court permits one-time Karthigai deepam lighting at Thiruparankundram Hill, stays Madras High Court findings
  • Supreme Court dismisses Karnataka’s plea to reinstate bike taxi ban, allows Ola, Uber and Rapido services
  • Supreme Court strikes down UP laws denying pension benefits for pre-regularisation service of work-charged employees
  • Rajasthan High Court denies interim relief to IAS officer Shikhar Agrawal in ACB probe over 64 villa purchases by family
  • Supreme Court transfers pan-India unauthorised construction case from Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah’s bench to Justice BV Nagarathna-led bench

Recent Comments

  1. Phone Tracking In India - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA
  2. Section 437A of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA
  3. The Evolution of Indian Penal Code 1860: Key Provisions and Relevance Today - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA

Follow us for more

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
YouTube
Instagram
DisclaimerPrivacy PolicyTerms and Conditions
All Rights Reserved © 2023
  • Login
  • Sign Up
Forgot Password?
Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.