LAWYER SIBLING LOGO (1)
  • Home
  • Blogs
  • News
  • Updates
  • Constitution
    • Constitutional Laws
  • Laws
    • Civil Law
    • Criminal Law
    • Family Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Business Law
    • Cyber & IT Law
    • Employee Law
    • Finance Law
    • International Law
  • Special Act
    • Motor Vehicles Act (MV Act)
    • Consumer Protection Act
    • Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Act (NDPS)
    • The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO)
  • Bare Act

The New Censors: When Algorithms Silence The News

21/11/2026BlogNo Comments

By Dilip Bobb

The day after Diwali, as Delhi struggled under a thick blanket of post-festival smog, Times of India photojournalist Anindya Chattopadhyay uploaded photographs and videos showing the severely reduced visibility around the capital’s Lodhi Garden. His accompanying caption was pointed but simple: “after #diwali what we breathe”. He tagged Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta, Environment Minister Manjinder Singh Sirsa and the Commission for Air Quality Management.

Within hours, X locked his account, claiming that his posts violated the platform’s rules.

Chattopadhyay was understandably baffled. He had been documenting a public health emergency, not violating any community standards. The All India Working News Cameramen’s Association (WNCA) responded with a formal protest, writing to X’s Indian and global leadership and condemning the action as an attempt to silence visual journalism. The Association argued that Chattopadhyay was simply performing his professional duty in the public interest and that cameras were indispensable tools of journalism, not instruments to be censored.

Other media organisations also demanded an explanation. The irony was particularly striking: X’s automated moderation system had apparently categorised videos of low-visibility smog under its policy on “non-consensual nudity”.

It would be almost comic were the implications not so serious.

The incident has brought into focus a growing problem confronting journalists, independent media organisations and ordinary users: the increasingly arbitrary restriction of digital content in India, often without adequate explanation, transparency or an effective opportunity to challenge the action.

Across social media platforms, users have reported a surge in posts, reels and accounts carrying notices such as “Your post is unavailable in India”. Others have been informed that their content has been restricted under India’s Information Technology Rules, 2021. The restrictions have affected X, Instagram, Facebook and YouTube, with criticism of government policy, coverage of protests and politically sensitive reporting among the content attracting particular scrutiny.

The scale of the crackdown is striking. According to figures reported by The Indian Express, the centre issued close to 1,95,000 takedown orders relating to content on Instagram, Facebook and YouTube between March and July 2026. That amounts to approximately one order every 68 seconds. Instagram accounted for nearly 1,00,000 orders, Facebook around 80,000 and YouTube approximately 15,000. Meta-owned platforms thus accounted for the overwhelming majority.

Much of this activity is channelled through Sahyog, a portal operated by the Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre (I4C) under the Union home ministry. The portal allows government departments and law enforcement agencies to flag online material and transmit removal requests to intermediaries. Its central attraction is speed: requests can be processed and communicated to platforms through an increasingly automated system.

The figures are reinforced by other monitoring exercises. SFLC.in’s Free Speech Tracker recorded 351 cases of content or account restrictions in the 29 days preceding its October 30 report. Sources cited by The Hindu also indicated that Delhi Police had issued approximately 300 takedown requests over three months, most of which were acted upon by the platforms.

These figures represent different categories of requests and restrictions, but together they point to an expanding system of digital content control.

The change has been accelerated by the amended Information Technology Rules of 2026, which, reportedly, reduced the mandatory compliance window for intermediaries to remove content identified as unlawful following a valid government or court notice from 36 hours to just three hours. For platforms operating in one of the world’s largest social media markets, the commercial and regulatory incentive to comply quickly is obvious.

India has more than 500 million social media users, a vast mobile-first population and some of the world’s most affordable data services. For companies such as Meta and X, remaining on the right side of regulatory authorities is not a minor consideration. The pressure to respond rapidly to official requests is, therefore, considerable.

Two advisories issued by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) in October added to these concerns. On October 8, platforms were urged to exercise “enhanced diligence”, effectively prioritising complaints received from authorised government agencies. An advisory to Meta on October 10 specifically flagged content relating to public-order situations, warning that algorithmic amplification could potentially aggravate tensions.

The timing was significant. The advisories followed protests against the chief election commissioner and the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise, during which social media became an important vehicle for criticism and mobilisation.

Several users subsequently reported restrictions on their content. Cockroach Janta Party leader Ashutosh Ranka alleged that thousands of Instagram accounts had been restricted in India and lakhs of videos removed during the protests. Satirist and lyricist Varun Grover said Instagram had taken down his satirical poem questioning the government’s Viksit Bharat 2047 promise. The notification he shared cited a legal requirement under India’s IT framework.

Other users who posted critical photographs, videos and commentary reported similar restrictions. The Hindu also reported on MeitY’s advisory to Meta and the shorter compliance deadlines under the amended rules. Yet, in a telling response, a senior MeitY official told Hindustan Times on October 30: “We are not sending these takedowns. Ask Meta.”

This apparent disconnect between government denials and platform notifications lies at the heart of the controversy. If a restriction is imposed in response to a government request, who is responsible for it? And if the platform is merely complying with an official communication, how is the affected user to identify the authority behind the decision and challenge its legality?

THE SAHYOG QUESTION

The Sahyog portal has become the focal point of this debate. Critics argue that it enables government departments and police agencies to seek the removal of online material without necessarily following the more stringent safeguards prescribed for formal blocking orders under Section 69A of the Information Technology Act, 2000.

X itself challenged the portal before the Karnataka High Court, describing it as a “censorship portal”. The company argued that Section 79(3)(b) of the IT Act, which deals with the conditions under which intermediaries retain safe-harbour protection from liability for user-generated content, does not independently confer powers on government officials to block online material.

According to X’s court filings, officers from the home, defence, railways and finance ministries, along with police officials in more than 30 states and Union Territories, had been authorised to issue notices through the portal.

The Karnataka High Court dismissed X’s petition in September 2025, describing Sahyog as an instrument of public good. X has appealed the decision.

The controversy was compounded by the government’s own acknowledgement that an Indian Railways notice directing X to remove a viral video of a woman driving on railway tracks in Telangana had exceeded the department’s statutory powers. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta described the episode as an “isolated incident”.

The distinction between Sections 69A and 79 is crucial. Section 69A empowers the central government or its authorised officers to direct the blocking of public access to online information on specified grounds, including sovereignty and integrity of India, defence, security, public order and friendly relations with foreign States.

In its landmark 2015 judgment in Shreya Singhal vs Union of India, the Supreme Court upheld Section 69A, emphasising the procedural safeguards built into the blocking framework. These include recording reasons for blocking, providing an opportunity of hearing to affected parties in appropriate circumstances and subjecting decisions to review by a designated committee.

Section 79, on the other hand, provides intermediaries with conditional protection from liability for third-party content. Section 79(3)(b) deals with circumstances in which this safe-harbour protection may be lost if an intermediary fails to act upon legally valid notifications.

The concern is that government agencies may be using the latter provision to achieve content removal without necessarily invoking the safeguards attached to Section 69A. In effect, critics argue, a route designed to regulate intermediary liability could become an alternative mechanism for censorship.

The rules governing who can issue such intimations have also undergone changes. Following concerns over the authority of officials empowered to demand removal, amendments to Rule 3(1)(d) sought to restrict the power to specified senior officers, including joint secretary-level or equivalent officials, director-level officers and police officers of deputy inspector general rank or above.

The courts have begun examining the consequences of these provisions.

On October 5, the Punjab and Haryana High Court set aside a notice that had resulted in the blocking of the Facebook page of Haryana 24 News Network. The Court found that the notice had been issued by an officer below the prescribed DIG rank and that compliance with the mandatory monthly review requirement had not been demonstrated. It also ruled that users must receive a copy of the takedown intimation when it is sent to a platform, enabling them to challenge the restriction.

The ruling was significant because it recognised that transparency is not a procedural luxury. Without knowing who ordered a restriction and on what grounds, an affected user cannot meaningfully contest it.

The Digital News Publishers Association has also challenged the proposed provisions before the Supreme Court, arguing that journalists and digital news organisations require appropriate exemptions to protect press freedom.

WHEN MACHINES MAKE THE DECISIONS

Government orders are only one part of the problem. The other is the growing dependence of social media companies on automated moderation and compliance systems.

Chattopadhyay’s experience illustrates how these systems can malfunction. Uploading several photographs and videos in quick succession, particularly while tagging prominent government accounts, may trigger X’s authenticity and spam filters. Legitimate news reporting can consequently be mistaken for coordinated spam or bot activity.

The consequences are potentially more serious when automated systems are linked directly to government takedown mechanisms.

Meta, which receives the largest share of India’s takedown requests, has reportedly integrated an application programming interface (API) with the Sahyog portal to facilitate faster processing of official requests. In practice, this raises the possibility of content being removed automatically, without meaningful human scrutiny of the material or its wider journalistic and public-interest context.

The three-hour compliance deadline makes this particularly troubling. A platform faced with the possibility of regulatory consequences has little incentive to undertake a detailed examination of every request before acting. The safer commercial option is often to remove first and examine later, if at all.

The problem is compounded by the limited transparency available to users. Meta discloses details of legal content-removal requests in many jurisdictions, but India is among seven countries for which it has cited legal obligations and regulatory considerations as reasons for withholding such disclosures.

For journalists and ordinary users, the result can be a digital blackout without a clear explanation of its origin.

There is also a significant difference between a temporary account lock and a formal content-blocking order. Under X’s enforcement guidelines, an account lock may be a temporary security or rule-enforcement measure, often reversible through simple verification of a phone number or email address. A government-directed restriction, however, may involve a much more consequential legal process.

The distinction is frequently lost on users confronted with an unexplained notification. Even where a restriction can eventually be reversed, the immediate damage may already have been done. News organisations, independent journalists, commentators and small digital enterprises increasingly depend on these platforms for visibility, audience engagement and income. A prolonged suspension can, therefore, become a question of professional and financial survival.

Civil society organisations, including the Internet Freedom Foundation, have challenged excessive restrictions and occasionally secured restoration of accounts through legal intervention. But such successes remain limited against the scale of the emerging system.

THE COURTS AND THE CONSTITUTIONAL LINE

India’s judicial record on online expression has not always been uniform, but the Supreme Court has repeatedly recognised the importance of protecting free speech in the digital space.

The 2015 Shreya Singhal judgment remains a constitutional landmark. Apart from upholding the safeguards under Section 69A, the Court struck down Section 66A of the IT Act in its entirety, holding that its vague and overbroad provisions violated the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a).

In March 2025, the Supreme Court, while dealing with a challenge arising from a Delhi High Court ruling, reiterated that courts must exercise considerable restraint when criticism is directed at judges and judicial institutions. The two-judge bench observed that requiring the removal of content merely because it was critical could be incompatible with freedom of the press.

In another significant intervention, the Supreme Court quashed a police notice issued to X seeking user data relating to a journalist who had reported on an alleged scam involving donations to the Ayodhya Ram temple. The Court emphasised that fishing expeditions capable of compromising journalistic sources offend the principles of proportionality and press freedom.

More recently, a Supreme Court bench expressed deep concern over children between 12 and 15 accessing social media platforms and warned that it could issue binding directions to regulate intermediaries under the IT Act if the government failed to act.

These developments underline the difficult balance courts must maintain between free expression and legitimate concerns involving public order, national security and the protection of vulnerable users. But they also reinforce a fundamental constitutional principle: restrictions on speech must have a clear legal basis and satisfy the tests of necessity, proportionality and procedural fairness.

The difficulty is that the digital ecosystem is moving much faster than the legal safeguards designed to regulate it. Government agencies can flag content through Sahyog, platforms can process requests through automated systems, and the compliance window can expire in just three hours. The affected journalist or user, meanwhile, may have to navigate a lengthy grievance process that can stretch to 90 days before obtaining meaningful relief.

The result is an increasingly asymmetrical system. The State and the platforms have the technology and institutional machinery to restrict content almost immediately. The individual whose speech has been restricted often has neither the information nor the resources to challenge the decision effectively.

The removal of a photograph documenting Delhi’s pollution may appear a relatively minor incident in this larger scheme of things. But it illustrates the danger of allowing automated systems, opaque government communications and commercially driven platform compliance to determine what the public can see and read.

The real issue is not whether governments should be able to remove genuinely unlawful or dangerous material. They should, within the limits of the law. It is whether that power can be exercised through opaque processes that leave journalists and citizens without timely notice, meaningful remedies or access to the constitutional safeguards that protect free expression.

When the machinery of digital censorship operates in seconds, while the machinery of justice takes months, freedom of speech is left fighting a battle on unequal terms.

—The writer is former Senior Managing Editor, India Legal magazine

The post The New Censors: When Algorithms Silence The News appeared first on India Legal.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Nvidia, AI and the Price of Power
  • Contempt Of Court: Where Does Criticism End?
  • When The Law Begins To Believe Fiction
  • The Judgment That Never Was
  • The New Censors: When Algorithms Silence The News

Recent Comments

  1. Phone Tracking In India - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA
  2. Section 437A of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA
  3. The Evolution of Indian Penal Code 1860: Key Provisions and Relevance Today - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA

Follow us for more

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
YouTube
Instagram
DisclaimerPrivacy PolicyTerms and Conditions
All Rights Reserved © 2023
  • Login
  • Sign Up
Forgot Password?
Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.