A Supreme Court-appointed panel has urged the central government to withdraw the proposed Transgender Amendment Bill, raising serious concerns about its potential impact on the rights and dignity of transgender individuals. The panel, constituted to review issues affecting the transgender community, noted that several provisions in the draft law could undermine the very protections it seeks to establish.
The committee, headed by retired Justice Asha Menon, has written to the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment highlighting concerns about several provisions in the amendment and requesting a reconsideration of the law.
According to the panel’s observations, the bill risks diluting key safeguards that were previously recognized, particularly those aligned with the principles of equality, autonomy, and self-identification. One of the major points of contention is the perceived increase in bureaucratic control over gender recognition, which could make it harder for individuals to assert their identity without intrusive procedures.
The panel also highlighted that the bill does not adequately reflect the spirit of earlier judicial directions that emphasized respect for self-identification and non-discrimination. Instead of strengthening inclusion, the proposed amendments may inadvertently create additional barriers in accessing education, employment, healthcare, and social welfare.
Members of the panel stressed the importance of meaningful consultation with the transgender community before introducing any legislative changes. They argued that policies affecting marginalized groups must be shaped by their lived experiences to ensure fairness and effectiveness.
In its recommendation, the panel called for a more inclusive and rights-based approach. It suggested that the government revisit the draft, engage in wider dialogue, and align the legislation with constitutional values and international human rights standards.
The development has sparked renewed debate around the need for sensitive and progressive policymaking. Activists and advocacy groups have echoed the panel’s concerns, emphasizing that any law governing transgender rights must prioritize dignity, autonomy, and equal opportunity.
As discussions continue, the government’s response to the panel’s recommendation will be closely watched, given the broader implications for human rights and social justice in the country.
The post Supreme Court panel led by Justice Asha Menon urges Centre to withdraw Transgender Amendment Bill appeared first on India Legal.