The Supreme Court has clarified that a lawsuit cannot be dismissed at the very start (under Order VII Rule 11) just because it might be barred by Order II Rule 2 of the CPC (no one should be vexed twice for the same cause).
The bench of Justice BV Nagarathna and Justice Ujjal Bhuyan made the observation while hearing an appeal against the decision of the Madras High Court dismissed the suit under Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC (mandatory provision that requires a court to reject a plaint at the threshold if the suit appears, from the statements made in the plaint).
The dispute arose out of familial property transactions involving a contested Power of Attorney allegedly obtained through coercion. While an earlier suit had been filed seeking protection of possession and accounts, a subsequent suit sought declaratory and injunctive reliefs. The defendants contended that the latter suit was barred under Order II Rule 2 CPC, arguing that the plaintiffs had omitted to claim all available reliefs in the earlier proceedings.
After hearing the arguments and considering the provision, the judgment delivered by Justice Nagarathna states that Order II Rule 2 CPC does not bar the filing of a suit; it only restricts the grant of certain claims if they should have been raised earlier, which requires evidence to determine. In contrast, Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC applies where the suit itself is barred by law, allowing the plaint to be rejected at the outset based on its contents. Therefore, a bar under Order II Rule 2 cannot be used as a ground to reject a plaint under Order VII Rule 11(d).
The Supreme Court struck down High Court’s order stating that it omitted in doing a detailed analysis of both the suits at the pre-trial stage of evaluating the maintainability of the suit.
This ruling strengthens procedural fairness by ensuring that litigants are not denied adjudication on merits due to premature technical objections, thereby preserving the integrity of civil adjudication.
The post Supreme Court says Order II Rule bar not ground for early rejection of plaint appeared first on India Legal.