The Tamil Nadu government has defended its position on the Karthigai Deepam tradition at Thirupparankundram hill before the Supreme Court, asserting that the ceremonial lamp has historically been lit at the Deepa Mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar Temple and not at the hilltop. Opposing a petition seeking a permanent lamp at the Deepathoon, the State has maintained that the proposed changes have no basis in established religious custom and could disturb the existing administrative and legal arrangements governing the temple.
In a counter-affidavit filed before the apex court, Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Department Commissioner Dr T.G. Vinay contended that the Karthigai Deepam has been lit at the traditional location for more than 150 years in accordance with Agamic practices and the advice of the temple’s Sthanikars. The State categorically denied the existence of any established custom or historical practice of lighting the festival lamp at the summit of the hill.
The affidavit has been filed in response to a writ petition instituted by Hindu Dharma Parishad, represented by K.K. Ramesh, seeking directions for the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) to assume control of the entire temple and hill, installation of a lamp at the Deepathoon to remain illuminated round the clock, and lighting of the entire hill during the Karthigai Deepam festival.
Describing the petition as misconceived and an abuse of the judicial process, the State argued that none of the reliefs sought by the petitioner was founded on an enforceable legal entitlement, an established religious custom or the violation of any fundamental right. It further contended that granting such directions would undermine the settled ownership and statutory administration of the temple.
The State maintained that decisions concerning religious ceremonies, including the location and manner of lighting the Karthigai Deepam, fall within the authority of the temple administration and cannot be dictated by individual devotees or private organisations. It said the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy Temple, regarded as the first among the six sacred abodes of Lord Subramania, is a public religious institution governed under the Tamil Nadu Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1959.
Strongly opposing the proposal to maintain a permanent lamp at the Deepathoon, the State asserted that such a practice was unknown to the temple’s established traditions. It also objected to the demand for illuminating the entire hill, arguing that the proposal could create serious law-and-order complications at a location with a history of communal sensitivities.
The affidavit further challenged the proposed transfer of the temple and the hill to the ASI, contending that the archaeological body’s mandate to protect monuments and heritage structures cannot be extended to taking over the administration of a functioning religious institution. The State maintained that the temple’s statutory management and religious affairs must remain with the authorities legally entrusted with their administration.
The government also relied on the existing legal framework and earlier judicial proceedings concerning the location of the ceremonial lamp. It referred to the 1996 Madras High Court ruling governing the traditional practice and argued that any alteration in the established arrangement could not be introduced through the present writ petition.
The State additionally referred to the settled ownership of the hill under a 1923 civil court decree, which was subsequently restored by the Privy Council in 1931. It contended that the ASI’s protection extends only to specified archaeological features, including the rock-cut cave and inscriptions, and does not confer authority over the entire hill or the temple.
The State has also questioned the maintainability of the petition under Article 32 of the Constitution, arguing that the petitioner has failed to demonstrate infringement of any fundamental right warranting the Supreme Court’s intervention. It has sought dismissal of the plea at the threshold, with costs.
A Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi is scheduled to hear the matter on November 17. The Court is yet to examine the State’s contentions in the counter-affidavit.
The post Thirupparankundram Deepam Row: Tamil Nadu tells Supreme Court 150-year-old tradition is to light lamp at Deepa Mandapam, opposes ASI takeover appeared first on India Legal.
