Senior Advocate Vipin Sanghi, appearing for the petitioner, contended before the Supreme Court that Rule 12 had effectively undermined the principle of rotation. He submitted that the petitioner’s constituency had never been reserved and that, just when it appeared due for reservation, the authorities decided to restart the rotation exercise. According to him, this could indefinitely deprive constituencies with a relatively lower SC/ST population of an opportunity to be included in the reservation cycle.
Justice Bagchi questioned whether a voter or candidate could claim a right to have a particular constituency reserved. He observed that the government was entitled to determine the cut-off date for the rotation exercise. Sanghi, however, questioned whether the State could disregard the rotation process that had already been underway.
Rejecting the challenge, the Court explained that the constitutional framework and applicable rules envisage reservation of seats in proportion to the SC/ST population in the concerned local body. It further noted that rotation of reserved constituencies is to be undertaken in descending order of the SC/ST population. However, the precise mechanism and timeframe for implementing the rotation remain within the State Government’s discretion.
The Bench held that the decision under Rule 12 to treat the next election following the 2025 amendment as the starting point for rotation did not violate the principles of reservation or rotation. It accordingly dismissed the special leave petition while clarifying that the petitioner would remain at liberty to make a representation to the State Government seeking reconsideration of the rotation framework in accordance with law.
The Supreme Court has held that neither a voter nor an electoral candidate can claim a vested right to have a particular constituency reserved for Scheduled Castes (SCs) or Scheduled Tribes (STs), observing that the manner and timing of rotation of reserved seats fall within the discretion of the State Government.
A Bench of Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana made the observation while dismissing a special leave petition challenging Rule 12 of the Maharashtra Zilla Parishads and Panchayat Samitis (Manner and Rotation of Reservation of Seats) Rules, 2025.
The petitioner had approached the Bombay High Court seeking to invalidate the provision on the ground that it violated Article 14 of the Constitution. The High Court had rejected the challenge, holding that no individual could claim an entitlement to reservation in a particular constituency. It had also taken note of changes in population figures and the proposed alteration of constituency boundaries.
Senior Advocate Vipin Sanghi, appearing for the petitioner, contended before the Supreme Court that Rule 12 had effectively undermined the principle of rotation. He submitted that the petitioner’s constituency had never been reserved and that, just when it appeared due for reservation, the authorities decided to restart the rotation exercise. According to him, this could indefinitely deprive constituencies with a relatively lower SC/ST population of an opportunity to be included in the reservation cycle.
Justice Bagchi questioned whether a voter or candidate could claim a right to have a particular constituency reserved. He observed that the government was entitled to determine the cut-off date for the rotation exercise. Sanghi, however, questioned whether the State could disregard the rotation process that had already been underway.
Rejecting the challenge, the Court explained that the constitutional framework and applicable rules envisage reservation of seats in proportion to the SC/ST population in the concerned local body. It further noted that rotation of reserved constituencies is to be undertaken in descending order of the SC/ST population. However, the precise mechanism and timeframe for implementing the rotation remain within the State Government’s discretion.
The Bench held that the decision under Rule 12 to treat the next election following the 2025 amendment as the starting point for rotation did not violate the principles of reservation or rotation. It accordingly dismissed the special leave petition while clarifying that the petitioner would remain at liberty to make a representation to the State Government seeking reconsideration of the rotation framework in accordance with law.
The post No voter or candidate has vested right to reservation in particular constituency: Supreme Court upholds Government’s discretion over seat rotation appeared first on India Legal.
