The Delhi High Court on Tuesday disposed of journalist Paranjoy Guha Thakurta’s appeal challenging an interim injunction that restrained him from publishing further reports concerning Indiabulls and its promoter Sameer Gehlaut. The Court directed the trial court to take up the pending injunction application and decide it expeditiously.
Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri passed the order after being informed that the interim injunction application was scheduled for further consideration before the trial court on November 21. The High Court clarified that, subject to the appearance of all the defendants, the trial court should ensure an early disposal of the application.
The appeal arose from an October 24 order passed by the Principal District and Sessions Judge at Patiala House Courts in a defamation suit instituted by Indiabulls Nests Limited and Gehlaut against 41 defendants. The trial court had directed the removal of a seven-year-old article co-authored by Guha Thakurta and imposed restrictions on further publication of content concerning the plaintiffs.
The article, titled ‘The Maze of Political Links of Indiabull’s Sameer Gehlaut’, was co-authored by Guha Thakurta and Sourodipto Sanyal and originally published on NewsClick on September 30, 2019. It was subsequently reproduced on the journalist’s website.
Challenging the injunction, Guha Thakurta contended that the order imposed an unconstitutional prior restraint on journalistic expression by prohibiting him from publishing any further material concerning the plaintiffs. He argued that the sweeping restriction was vague and disproportionate and would impede his ability to report on matters involving Indiabulls, including developments relating to a CBI inquiry directed by the Supreme Court.
The journalist also questioned the procedure adopted by the trial court, arguing that the injunction had been granted without prior notice to him and without recording adequate reasons as required under Order XXXIX Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure. He further submitted that the article had remained in the public domain for nearly seven years before the defamation proceedings were initiated.
During Tuesday’s hearing, Senior Advocate Rajiv Nayar, appearing for Indiabulls and Gehlaut, informed the High Court that a similar appeal filed by Delhi Press Patra Prakashan had earlier been disposed of on November 4, with directions to the trial court to consider the interim injunction application.
Taking note of the November 21 listing and the fact that all defendants had been informed of the hearing, the High Court closed Guha Thakurta’s appeal, leaving the question of continuation of the injunction to be considered by the trial court.
The High Court’s order does not adjudicate the merits of the journalist’s challenge to the injunction, with the issues concerning the restraint on publication remaining before the trial court.
The post Delhi High Court closes Paranjoy Guha Thakurta’s appeal against Indiabulls gag order,directs trial court to decide plea expeditiously appeared first on India Legal.
