LAWYER SIBLING LOGO (1)
  • Home
  • Blogs
  • News
  • Updates
  • Constitution
    • Constitutional Laws
  • Laws
    • Civil Law
    • Criminal Law
    • Family Law
    • Real Estate Law
    • Business Law
    • Cyber & IT Law
    • Employee Law
    • Finance Law
    • International Law
  • Special Act
    • Motor Vehicles Act (MV Act)
    • Consumer Protection Act
    • Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Act (NDPS)
    • The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO)
  • Bare Act

Supreme Court declines urgent hearing of plea seeking recall of split verdict on Election Commissioners appointment law

20/11/2026BlogNo Comments

The Supreme Court on Friday declined a request for urgent listing of an application seeking recall of its September 2026 split verdict on the constitutional validity of the law governing the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (ECs). The application alleges a conflict of interest involving Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, who was part of the two-judge Bench that delivered the divided opinion.

A Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana asked the applicant to raise the objection before the five-judge Constitution Bench that is expected to examine the constitutional questions arising from the challenge to the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.

Advocate Prashant Bhushan mentioned the recall application before the CJI-led Bench and sought its placement before the original Bench comprising Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma. He emphasised that the application specifically questioned the validity of the reference order on the ground of alleged conflict of interest and, therefore, ought to be considered by the judges who had passed it. Bhushan also pointed out that Justice Sharma was due to retire at the end of the following week, making an early hearing necessary.

The allegation stems from the fact that Justice Sharma’s son appears as counsel for the Election Commission of India. The application contends that this circumstance raised concerns regarding a potential conflict of interest in the proceedings concerning the validity of the 2023 legislation.

Responding to the request, the Bench indicated that the five-judge Constitution Bench could independently examine the objection and consider whether the reference itself was legally sustainable. Justice Joymalya Bagchi observed that the larger Bench was not bound by the reference and could frame an appropriate question concerning its validity, allowing the applicant to advance the allegation of bias before it.

Bhushan, however, maintained that the recall plea should be heard by the original Bench, arguing that the reference to a Constitution Bench had followed Justice Sharma’s dissenting opinion. He submitted that had Justice Sharma not disagreed with Justice Datta, the matter would not have been referred to a larger Bench.

CJI Surya Kant responded that Justice Datta had independently concluded that the matter warranted consideration by a Constitution Bench. Clarifying the circumstances in which the larger Bench was constituted, the CJI said his role had been confined to constituting the Bench after examining the judicial opinion and the concluding portion of the judgment.

Bhushan clarified that he was not questioning the CJI’s administrative decision but was insisting that the recall application should ordinarily be placed before the Bench whose order was under challenge.

The CJI-led Bench indicated that the application would be placed before the appropriate Bench when the matter was taken up, allowing the applicant to press the objection at that stage, following which a judicial order could be passed. When Bhushan again flagged Justice Sharma’s impending retirement, the Bench observed that recall applications could be considered even after a judge had demitted office, adding that Justice Datta, who presided over the original Bench, would continue to be available.

The September 2026 split verdict arose from petitions challenging the 2023 Act, particularly the statutory framework for selecting the CEC and Election Commissioners. Under the legislation, the selection committee comprises the Prime Minister, the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. The earlier arrangement, which included the Chief Justice of India in the selection panel, had been replaced by this composition.

While Justice Dipankar Datta held that the constitutional challenge could be adjudicated on the basis of principles already settled by the Supreme Court and did not require a reference to a larger Bench, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma took the view that substantial constitutional questions warranted examination by a five-judge Bench.

Despite their disagreement, both judges agreed on the procedural course of placing the matter before the CJI for consideration of a direct reference to a Constitution Bench. They also called for consideration of a permanent five-judge Bench to adjudicate substantial questions of constitutional interpretation.

The post Supreme Court declines urgent hearing of plea seeking recall of split verdict on Election Commissioners appointment law appeared first on India Legal.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Supreme Court permits one-time Karthigai deepam lighting at Thiruparankundram Hill, stays Madras High Court findings
  • Supreme Court dismisses Karnataka’s plea to reinstate bike taxi ban, allows Ola, Uber and Rapido services
  • Supreme Court strikes down UP laws denying pension benefits for pre-regularisation service of work-charged employees
  • Rajasthan High Court denies interim relief to IAS officer Shikhar Agrawal in ACB probe over 64 villa purchases by family
  • Supreme Court transfers pan-India unauthorised construction case from Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah’s bench to Justice BV Nagarathna-led bench

Recent Comments

  1. Phone Tracking In India - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA
  2. Section 437A of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA
  3. The Evolution of Indian Penal Code 1860: Key Provisions and Relevance Today - lawyer Sibling on The Constitution of INDIA

Follow us for more

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
YouTube
Instagram
DisclaimerPrivacy PolicyTerms and Conditions
All Rights Reserved © 2023
  • Login
  • Sign Up
Forgot Password?
Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.